Dental Expressions® -- From the CNA Claim Files
Wrong Tooth Extraction: Internal Referral and Treatment Verification
Wrong-tooth treatment is a preventable patient-safety event and an ongoing professional liability concern. Inaccurate tooth identification, referral communication, record review and treatment-site verification may contribute to these claims.
According to the Dental Professional Liability Claim Report: 2nd Edition, wrong tooth extractions were associated with 9 percent of surgical extractions and 22.9 percent of simple extractions for claims with $10,000 or more in paid indemnity.
The following case study illustrates how an internal referral and access to a shared electronic dental record may create a false sense that the requested treatment has already been fully verified.
Case Study
Practitioner: General dentist
Claimant: 55-year-old patient
Risk management topics: Wrong-tooth extraction; internal referrals; patient assessment; informed consent; treatment-site verification; recordkeeping
Facts:
A 55-year-old patient received ongoing care from a general dentist in a multi-dentist practice. During an examination, the dentist identified significant periodontal involvement affecting two posterior teeth in the upper right quadrant and recommended extraction.
Because another general dentist in the practice routinely performed more difficult extractions, the patient was referred internally for treatment. The electronic referral identified the teeth by number, and relevant digital radiographs were available in the shared record. However, the referral did not include an anatomic description or identify the images supporting the recommendation.
Several weeks later, the patient presented for the extraction appointment. The treating dentist reviewed the referral and available radiographs but did not independently reconcile the referral with the patient’s current clinical findings and treatment plan. The record also contained older images and documentation of treatment in the opposite quadrant.
Before the procedure, the dentist confirmed with the patient that she was having “two upper back teeth” removed. The patient signed an extraction consent form identifying the teeth by number but not by anatomic location.
After administering local anesthesia, the dentist extracted two maxillary posterior teeth on the patient’s left side.
While documenting the procedure, a dental assistant questioned whether the teeth corresponded with the referral. The dentist then reviewed the treatment plan and current radiographs and realized that the intended teeth were on the patient’s upper right.
The dentist informed the patient of the error. Although the mistakenly extracted teeth had preexisting restorations, neither had been planned for extraction. The two originally identified teeth still required treatment.
Key Allegations:
The patient asserted a professional liability claim against the treating dentist and practice. The allegations included:
- Extraction of the wrong teeth
- Failure to independently assess the patient and verify the treatment plan
- Inadequate review of the referral, clinical findings and diagnostic images
- Inadequate communication between the dentists
- Failure to conduct an effective time-out
- Failure to obtain informed consent for the extracted teeth
Alleged Injuries/Damages:
The patient alleged unnecessary loss of two permanent teeth, need for replacement and restorative treatment, additional treatment involving the originally intended teeth, additional expenses, pain and emotional distress.
Analysis:
Wrong-tooth cases present significant defense challenges because an irreversible procedure was performed at the wrong treatment site. In this case, several communication and verification failures contributed to the outcome.
Because the referral originated within the same practice and both dentists had access to the shared electronic record, the treating dentist may have assumed the treatment had already been verified. However, the referring dentist remained responsible for clearly communicating the diagnosis and requested treatment, while the treating dentist had an independent responsibility to assess the patient and verify that the requested treatment was appropriate.
The referral identified the teeth only by number. Tooth numbers provide an efficient means of communication. However, adding an anatomic description or identifying the teeth on a current image provides another layer of verification when prior treatment, missing teeth, tooth movement or inconsistent charting may create confusion.
Digital radiography has reduced some orientation and handling problems associated with conventional film but has not eliminated treatment-site risk. Incorrect image selection, labeling or orientation, or failure to correlate the image with the clinical examination may still contribute to errors.
The consent process also failed to identify the discrepancy. The dentist and patient confirmed only that two “upper back teeth” would be removed. Although the form listed tooth numbers, neither the signed form nor the patient’s confirmation substituted for independent treatment-site verification.
Earlier CNA wrong-tooth claims provide useful litigation lessons. In one case, referral and tooth-numbering errors contributed to extraction of the wrong teeth, underscoring the receiving dentist's independent responsibility to assess the patient and verify the treatment. In another, the record demonstrated that the dentist deliberately selected the disputed tooth following examination, diagnosis, discussion of alternatives and informed consent. Documentation identified both the tooth number and anatomic location, and the case resulted in a defense verdict.
These cases demonstrate an important distinction. A wrong-tooth allegation does not necessarily establish that an error occurred. When clinical judgment is disputed, comprehensive documentation may support the defense. When an actual wrong-site event occurs, inadequate communication and documentation can make the claim more difficult to defend.
Outcome:
Dental experts were unable to support the treating dentist's failure to reconcile the referral, clinical findings, treatment plan, diagnostic images and consent before the extractions.
Although the incomplete referral contributed to the event, it did not eliminate the treating dentist's responsibility to evaluate the patient and verify treatment. The defense was further limited by the absence of documented independent assessment, dentist-to-dentist clarification or completion of a time-out.
The parties resolved the claim through settlement, with a total incurred (settlement plus claim expenses) of $112,000. The settlement considered the unnecessary loss of two permanent teeth, replacement costs, the additional treatment required for the originally intended teeth and emotional distress.
Risk Management Considerations:
Wrong-tooth extractions are preventable, but prevention requires more than correct entry of a tooth number. Consider the following measures.
- Standardize referrals. Use a consistent process for internal and external referrals. Include the diagnosis, reason for referral, requested treatment, tooth numbers, pertinent findings and relevant diagnostic images. When appropriate, add an anatomic description, such as "upper right second molar." Do not assume that less information is necessary because dentists share an office or electronic record, and do not rely on the patient to communicate clinical details.
- Perform an independent assessment. Review the patient's history, clinical condition, treatment plan and relevant diagnostic information. Do not treat a referral as an instruction to perform an irreversible procedure without independent verification. If clinical findings do not correspond with the referral, contact the referring dentist, resolve the discrepancy and document the communication before treatment.
- Verify diagnostic images. Confirm that images belong to the correct patient, are current and diagnostically appropriate, display the correct side and orientation, and correspond with the referral and clinical examination. If the information is unclear or inconsistent, obtain additional imaging when clinically indicated.
- Conduct a time-out. Immediately before extraction, actively verify:
- Correct patient
- Correct procedure
- Correct tooth or teeth
- Correct quadrant and side
- Agreement among the referral, treatment plan, consent and images
- Completion of the informed-consent process
Whenever feasible, involve the dentist, a dental team member and the patient. If any information conflicts, stop until the discrepancy is resolved.
- Obtain and document informed consent. Discuss the diagnosis, proposed treatment, reasonable alternatives, material risks and consequences of declining treatment. For tooth-specific procedures, document both the tooth number and anatomic location when appropriate. A signed consent form does not replace independent verification of the treatment site.
- Encourage team members to speak up. Dental assistants and other team members may identify inconsistencies that others overlook. Establish a culture in which any team member can stop the process and question a tooth number, image, referral, consent form or treatment site.
- Review events and near misses. Evaluate whether referral design, charting, scheduling, image selection, consent procedures, workload or time-out compliance contributed to an error or near miss. Use the findings to improve procedures and educate the dental team.
If an adverse event occurs, address the patient’s clinical needs, communicate appropriately, preserve the original records and images, document follow-up care, and promptly notify the professional liability insurer.
Conclusion:
Wrong-tooth treatment is preventable in most cases, yet extraction-related claims continue to demonstrate the potential consequences of these errors. Clear referral communication, independent clinical assessment and a consistent treatment-site verification process can help reduce the risk. These safeguards remain important even when dentists practice together and share the same electronic patient record.
Resources
Article by: Ronald Zentz, RPh, DDS, FAGD, CPHRM
CNA Dental Risk Control
Created: 11/2026
____________
Disclaimer.
The information, examples and suggestions presented in this material have been developed from sources believed to be reliable as of the date they are cited, but they should not be construed as legal or other professional advice. CNA, Aon, Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., Dentist’s Advantage accepts no responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of this material and recommends the consultation with competent legal counsel and/or other professional advisors before applying this material in any particular factual situations. This material is for illustrative purposes and is not intended to constitute a contract. Please remember that only the relevant insurance policy can provide the actual terms, coverages, amounts, conditions and exclusions for an insured. All products and services may not be available in all states and may be subject to change without notice. Certain coverages may be provided by a surplus lines insurer. Surplus lines insurers do not generally participate in state guaranty funds, and insureds are therefore not protected by such funds. The claims examples are hypothetical situations based on actual matters. Settlement amounts are approximations. Certain facts and identifying characteristics were changed to protect confidentiality and privacy. Any references to non-CNA, non-Aon, AIS, Dentist’s Advantage websites are provided solely for convenience, and CNA, Aon, and AIS disclaim any responsibility with respect to such websites. “CNA” is a registered trademark of CNA Financial Corporation. Certain CNA Financial Corporation subsidiaries use the “CNA” trademark in connection with insurance underwriting and claims activities. This material is not for further distribution without the express consent of CNA. Copyright © 2026 CNA. All rights reserved.
Dentist's Advantage is a division of Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., a licensed producer in all states; (TX 13695); (AR 100106022); in CA & MN, AIS Affinity Insurance Agency, Inc. (CA 0795465); in OK, AIS Affinity Insurance Services Inc.; in CA, Aon Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., (CA 0G94493), Aon Direct Insurance Administrators and Berkely Insurance Agency and in NY, AIS Affinity Insurance Agency.